by Duke Matthus » Wed Nov 25, 2009 3:28 am
Yes and I had talked to the other party that controls the family with me and was originally for it. However I miss understood what he said and late is where the disagreement came. We had a misunderstanding of the scale at which it was going to be and that I mistook his using of Luthori troops as Colonial troops, which when cleared after talking with him later was fixed. This would solve that issue completely, and spell it out clearly, for at the moment then New Alduria is not Luthori but still Alduira's by the reason some are saying and thus would make the last 200 or 300 years of it being Luthori false.
As for Khaler's point:
The issue is that we are saying that it would not be Luthori, Alduria or Yishelem as seperate nations, they would be "States" in the Terran Empire, in other words the colonies would not be part of Luthori to begin with, so if luthori fell the colonies would still be part of the nation for the nation, Terran Empire, would still exist in Yishelem and Alduria. Now if all fell then the colonies would be up for grabs like the Namviet colonies were when I had Luthori take them from Jeb. No nation was left to claim them, and hell I even gave half of them to Delteria, who Jeb was at the time of the conquest of Namviet, by Jeb, was combinded with. I agree if the home nation is taken then by all means the colonies are theirs for the taking, however because this proposal would combind the nations as states, a part of one Empire, it would techincally be as you say. They would belong to that nation, the Terran Empire and if the whole Empire fell then so would the colonies. Now how the colonies would be broken up would be for the conquerors to decided, all I am suggesting is for sake of RP and for gods sake upkeep,. for I can tell you I may be in Alduria now, but I have done more work on those Colonies than any of the parties in Luthori (ICL is also to credit there, though he has worked more on the wiki of Luthori law and the military) and yet I am currently in Alduria holding together a very weak Empire that is held under treaties that contridict each other.
This would fix all of that and make it simple and quite frankly fair for all to be able to control and at the same time RP the colonies. It is far from Godmodding for Godmodding would mean you get something out of it that is an advantage to you. All this is doing is allowing us to official say and quite frankly run the colonies and the Empire in a much more easier way on all of us.
To compromise with you and prove my point Khalar, for I can see what you are arguing, I suggest we give it a shot of what I am proposing. If it is as you say and if it is not working then the Terran Empire can give them to certain nations that are members. A test period that will show that it is not godmodding, but simply realistic and quite frankly it is fair to those that are working together to share the benefits of their hard work as one. I will not deny your hard work in Yishelem, so why not work together to make the process I started under Jason of combinding the thrones into one throne. Make the Terran Throne make the colonies part of one nation and not all held together under different treaties that make no sense.
Long Live the Empire!!!!
And while we are at it, "Hail the Holy Britannian Empire!!!!!"