Autokrator15 wrote:This will upset the ballance of power,
I'm not sure if this is necessarily a bad thing. Actually, the overall implication of your post is that there are specific countries which are entitled to the elected seats. I'm also not sure how it would upset the balance of power. Tbh, I'm not even aware of what the balance of power is right now, or who the superpowers are right now, and it's not something I expect the players outside of the forum to know (or care about) either.
If others agree that certain countries are entitled to seats on the council, then perhaps we could copy the real UNSC and have some nations with permanent seats, and then the rest would be elected. If others would oppose that, then this idea that specific countries are entitled to these seats should fade.
Another overall implication of your post is that the Security Council would have power. I was hoping for its resolutions to be non-binding, and for it to just be something we can use for bragging rights OOC, or to be more influential (by having a more weighted but not imposing voice) IC.
Autokrator15 wrote:I know that the current ballance is only as it is now but over the course of this games history we can safely asume it doesnt change directly.
In looking at the game's history (as well as Terra's geology), I figured it made more sense for Indrala to be linked with Dovani than for it to be separated from it (though I'm not discounting Indrala's links with Seleya). The Gao-Showa and Gao-Soto ethnicities - if I'm not mistaken - are heavily based in Dovani.
Autokrator15 wrote:In Siggon's proposal the C seat is left without a major superpower.
I'm not sure why this is a bad thing, but I would welcome you to elaborate. In the real UN, the world is divided into regional groups. Not all regional groups have a superpower in them. Actually, the USA and all the Western powers are in a regional group together, while Russia is in another, and China and Iran are in another. There are 15 Security Council seats, with 5 being reserved for permanent members and the next 10 being elected among the groups (3 for Africa, 2 for Latin America and the Caribbean, 1 for Eastern Europe, and 1 for the Western European metagroup). You can imagine that it's not necessarily regional powers that necessarily get these seats; countries as small as Jamaica, Trinidad & Tobago, and Singapore have been on the Security Council, with Jamaica having been on it twice.
Autokrator15 wrote:D, now has two major superpowers fighting for the same seat. Trigunia and Indrala are both superpowers and Hutori is a majorpower
1) Hutori is not in the same seat as Trigunia and Indrala, in my proposal.
2) It's possible for 2 nations in the same seat to get elected, which is why there is a Seat E.