Page 16 of 24

Re: Real-Life Equivalents Index: feedback

PostPosted: Sat Mar 30, 2019 10:34 am
by Auditorii
Edmund wrote:"Gospel: Annunciation" is pointless. Gospel is from Old English gōdspel (gōd (good) + spel (news)), a calque of the Greek euangélion (good news). There's no reason for it to require a name different to the one in RL.

"Book of Bliss"? Why? Quran translates to "the recitation".

Katub I believe translates to "written", so...

Allah translates to God. There's no point in renaming Allah Akim.

"There's no reason for X to require a name different to the one in RL" really applies to all of these.


Considering the amount of lore and usage of these terms it shouldn’t be changed.

Re: Real-Life Equivalents Index: feedback

PostPosted: Sat Mar 30, 2019 1:22 pm
by Reddy
Edmund wrote:"Gospel: Annunciation" is pointless. Gospel is from Old English gōdspel (gōd (good) + spel (news)), a calque of the Greek euangélion (good news). There's no reason for it to require a name different to the one in RL.

"Book of Bliss"? Why? Quran translates to "the recitation".

Katub I believe translates to "written", so...

Allah translates to God. There's no point in renaming Allah Akim.

"There's no reason for X to require a name different to the one in RL" really applies to all of these.


You are technically right and I believe that this is the not first time it has been pointed out (to me at least) The process has not been one based exclusively on reason, it was part of a movement to reject the use of names associated with all real-life religions, regardless of the origin of their names. Like Auditor, I think the very robust lore and usage that has developed around the equivalent names makes a change unwelcome and potentially confusing.

Re: Real-Life Equivalents Index: feedback

PostPosted: Sat Mar 30, 2019 2:34 pm
by Edmund
At the very least in my opinion Katub should be changed. It would be the easiest to retcon and the name doesn't actually work.

Re: Real-Life Equivalents Index: feedback

PostPosted: Sat Nov 02, 2019 10:05 pm
by nicolas01
I don't see an official equivalent for Québec, so what about this?

Québec: Lourenne
Québécois: Lourennais

Re: Real-Life Equivalents Index: feedback

PostPosted: Mon Nov 04, 2019 12:26 am
by Auditorii
nicolas01 wrote:I don't see an official equivalent for Québec, so what about this?

Québec: Lourenne
Québécois: Lourennais


That isn't how real-life equivalent's work. Lourenne has not been played as Quebec to the best of my knowledge, thus this is not appropriate.

Re: Real-Life Equivalents Index: feedback

PostPosted: Mon Nov 04, 2019 7:49 pm
by nicolas01
Auditorii wrote:
nicolas01 wrote:I don't see an official equivalent for Québec, so what about this?

Québec: Lourenne
Québécois: Lourennais


That isn't how real-life equivalent's work. Lourenne has not been played as Quebec to the best of my knowledge, thus this is not appropriate.


Then tell me which nation I can play as Québec? It has to be a french speaking nation located outside of the old continent.

Re: Real-Life Equivalents Index: feedback

PostPosted: Mon Nov 04, 2019 10:04 pm
by Auditorii
nicolas01 wrote:
Auditorii wrote:
nicolas01 wrote:I don't see an official equivalent for Québec, so what about this?

Québec: Lourenne
Québécois: Lourennais


That isn't how real-life equivalent's work. Lourenne has not been played as Quebec to the best of my knowledge, thus this is not appropriate.


Then tell me which nation I can play as Québec? It has to be a french speaking nation located outside of the old continent.


This isn't the place for discussion. You're welcome to comb through the nations and see which might fit your fancy.

Re: Real-Life Equivalents Index: feedback

PostPosted: Sun Apr 19, 2020 11:48 pm
by robmark0000
Is there French Revolution in the Particracy world?

Re: Real-Life Equivalents Index: feedback

PostPosted: Mon Apr 20, 2020 12:19 am
by Luis1p
robmark0000 wrote:Is there French Revolution in the Particracy world?



Not really. Each Canrillaise nation (Alduria, Kanjor, Lourenne, Rildanor) has gone through some sort of civil war/conflict in its past. There hasn't been a Canrillaise revolution similar to that of the French revolution in PT, but you will find a lot Republican Vs. Monarchist wars, nations switching governments and countries entering unions. I guess ou could call them revolutions, but nothing similar to the scale of the French revolution.

Re: Real-Life Equivalents Index: feedback

PostPosted: Mon Apr 20, 2020 12:21 am
by robmark0000
Luis1p wrote:
robmark0000 wrote:Is there French Revolution in the Particracy world?



Not really. Each Canrillaise nation (Alduria, Kanjor, Lourenne, Rildanor) has gone through some sort of civil war/conflict in its past. There hasn't been a Canrillaise revolution similar to that of the French revolution in PT, but you will find a lot Republican Vs. Monarchist wars, nations switching governments and countries entering unions. I you could call them revolutions, but nothing similar to the scales if the French revolution.


Thank you.